Jump directly to the content
Murder mystery

Investigators re-examine mystery of six people who confessed to a murder they may not have committed… and there was no physical evidence to prove they did

The eye-opening documentary asks more questions about the killings that shook Iceland

SIX people confessed to the killings of two men in 1974, despite allegedly having no recollection of the crime.

Decades after the gang was sentenced without any physical evidence linking them to murder, experts are re-examining the mysterious case.

 Erla Bolladottir confessed to a killing when she was being interview by cops for a petty crime
7
Erla Bolladottir confessed to a killing when she was being interview by cops for a petty crime

BBC Four documentary Out Of Thin Air: Murder In Iceland, takes a look back at the baffling case.

In 1974 Iceland, the population was around 200,000 people and there was a low crime rate.

When two people who shared the same surname, despite not being related, mysteriously vanished, the public began pressurising investigators for answers.

Teenager Erla Bolldottir was questioned for an unrelated petty crime in December 1975.

But before she left the interrogation room, she had confessed to playing a part in the murder.

Bolldottir recalled having a strange dream on the night of Gudmunder Einarsson's disappearance.

 Sæv­ar Ciesi­elski was seen as a Charles Manson-style cult leader of the gang
7
Sæv­ar Ciesi­elski was seen as a Charles Manson-style cult leader of the gang
 The documentary claims Tryggvi Leifsson was put through 655 days of solitary confinement during the investigation
7
The documentary claims Tryggvi Leifsson was put through 655 days of solitary confinement during the investigation

In this dream, she remembered hearing her boyfriend Sævar and his friends muttering outside her window.

Investigators latched onto this shred of information, suggesting that her memory could have been hazy because of the trauma of witnessing a murder.

Sævar Ciesielski and his friends Kirstjan Vidarsson, Tryggvi Leifsson, Albert Skatason and Gudjon Skarphedinsson  were called in for questioning.

 Forensic Psychologist Dr Gísli Guðjónsson, is one of the experts being called on to re-examine the case
7
Forensic Psychologist Dr Gísli Guðjónsson, is one of the experts being called on to re-examine the caseCredit: BBC
 Police authorities have been accused of using torture methods on the suspects, including Albert Skaftason (pictured)
7
Police authorities have been accused of using torture methods on the suspects, including Albert Skaftason (pictured)

During this time, the suspects were questioned for prolonged periods of times.

According to the BBC investigation, Sævar spent 615 days in solitary confinement and was interrogated for 340 hours in total.

Disturbingly, officers are also accused of inflicting sleep and water torture on the inmates.

After giving confessions, the suspects later retracted them and claimed they had no memory of the crime.

 Should the confessions be disregarded? Some experts think so. Pictured: Gudjon Skarphedinsson
7
Should the confessions be disregarded? Some experts think so. Pictured: Gudjon Skarphedinsson
 Kristjan Vidarsson now lives alone in Reykjavik and rarely talks about the case
7
Kristjan Vidarsson now lives alone in Reykjavik and rarely talks about the case

So could it be possible that the six suspects were wrongly convicted?

Ciesielski's family are working to clear Sævar's name, after the convicted killer died on the streets in 2011.

The other five charged prisoners are out of jail, but they're yet to prove their innocence.

Decades after the supposed crime, the case remains highly controversial.

To find out more about the Geirfinnur case, tune in to Out Of Thin Air: Murder In Iceland on BBC Four tomorrow evening at 10pm.

Topics