Jump directly to the content
'MENTAL SUFFERING'

Parents of toddler dropped from Royal Caribbean cruise ship window can now sue for UNLIMITED damages

THE parents of a toddler who plunged 11 decks to her death on a Royal Caribbean cruise ship last July can now sue the company for unlimited damages, a judge ruled Wednesday.

Parents Alan, 41, and Kimberly Wiegand, 37, are allowed to sue the cruise line for unlimited damages a judge ruled.

Alan and Kimberly Wiegand may now sue for unlimited damages in the death of their 18-month old daughter, Chloe, a judge ruled Thursday
11
Alan and Kimberly Wiegand may now sue for unlimited damages in the death of their 18-month old daughter, Chloe, a judge ruled ThursdayCredit: Enterprise News and Pictures
Grandfather Salvatore Anello was holding his granddaughter when she fell through a window and tumbled 150 feet to her death
11
Grandfather Salvatore Anello was holding his granddaughter when she fell through a window and tumbled 150 feet to her deathCredit: CBS
The toddler had been lifted so she could bang on the glass, as she loved to do at her brother's hockey games
11
The toddler had been lifted so she could bang on the glass, as she loved to do at her brother's hockey gamesCredit: Enterprise News and Pictures

Royal Caribbean tried to argue grandfather Salvatore Anello was the sole person responsible in 18-month old Chloe’s death, reports.

But US District Judge Donald L. Graham dismissed Royal Caribbean's motion to dismiss the case against Anello.

The granddad had lifted up little Chloe to let her bang on the glass of the Freedom of the Seas liner on July 7 last year as the ship was docked in , as she often loved to do at her brother’s hockey games.

However, in a horrific incident, Chloe fell through an opening of the window that could be slid open, crashing down 150 feet to her death.

Royal Caribbean has alleged that blue-green tinted handles on the windows would have clearly indicated the window was open, but Anello has argued that he is colorblind and therefore did not know the window was open.

Chloe’s South Bend, parents, who say they just want to ensure that what happened to their daughter will never happen to anyone else, can now potentially win “unlimited” damages in court after Thursday’s proceeding.

Anello has been charged with negligent homicide, as was open as he held Chloe out of it for 34 seconds.

Anello claimed because he is colorblind, he did not know the window was open
11
Anello claimed because he is colorblind, he did not know the window was openCredit: Courtesy of Lipcon, Margulies, Alsina & Winkleman, P.A
Video shows the moment Anello lifted his granddaughter up to look out the window
11
Video shows the moment Anello lifted his granddaughter up to look out the windowCredit: Enterprise News and Pictures
Chloe's parents say they know Anello would not have criminally harmed their daughter
11
Chloe's parents say they know Anello would not have criminally harmed their daughterCredit: Courtesy of Lipcon, Margulies, Alsina & Winkleman, P.A
Crime scene tape covers the area where Anello stood with Chloe before she fell
11
Crime scene tape covers the area where Anello stood with Chloe before she fellCredit: Courtesy of Lipcon, Margulies, Alsina & Winkleman, P.A.
Anello has maintained his innocence in his daughter's death
11
Anello has maintained his innocence in his daughter's deathCredit: Enterprise News and Pictures
Chloe at the glass at her brother's hockey game
11
Chloe at the glass at her brother's hockey gameCredit: Enterprise News and Pictures
The toddler tragically died in the July 7 incident when the ship was docked in Puerto Rico
11
The toddler tragically died in the July 7 incident when the ship was docked in Puerto RicoCredit: Enterprise News and Pictures
The cruise ship says Anello should have known the window was slid open, but he has said he did not know because he is colorblind
11
The cruise ship says Anello should have known the window was slid open, but he has said he did not know because he is colorblindCredit: Enterprise News and Pictures

The grandfather has maintained his innocence, and refused a plea deal for homicide.

Chloe’s parents have plead Puerto Rican authorities to drop the charges against Anello, could not have been criminally responsible in the toddler’s death.

Released right before her death.

A doctor who saw Chloe’s body after her death recalled the horrifying moment he saw her lying face-down, and his conversation with Anello after.

“I bent down and asked him what happened," the doctor said, according to the .

"While he was crying he just said: 'I thought the window was closed.'"

Anello is set for his next hearing on Feb. 24.

Video footage shows the moment Salvatore Anello dropped Chloe Wiegand from a Royal Caribbean ship in San Juan, Puerto Rico


Do you have a story for The US Sun team?

Email us at [email protected] or call 212 416 4552.


Topics