Jump directly to the content
SAFE OR SORRY?

New York’s largest hospital group probing if ventilators CAUSED coronavirus deaths

NEW York's largest hospital group is probing if ventilators CAUSED coronavirus deaths.

The investigation comes as cases in the nation's epicenter surpassed 369,000, with nearly 30,000 deaths.

A probe is evaluating whether ventilators contributed to more coronavirus deaths amid the pandemic in New York
6
A probe is evaluating whether ventilators contributed to more coronavirus deaths amid the pandemic in New YorkCredit: Chris Bergin
A patient is attached to a ventilator machine at St. Joseph's Hospital in Yonkers, New York
6
A patient is attached to a ventilator machine at St. Joseph's Hospital in Yonkers, New YorkCredit: AP:Associated Press

Northwell, which runs Lenox Hill, Long Island Jewish and Staten Island University hospitals among others, is probing whether the machines may have contributed to an increase in deaths, reported.

“One theory is if you put some patients on a ventilator, you might irritate the lungs more. That’s a theory we’re looking at,” Dr. Thomas McGinn, Northwell’s senior vice president and deputy physician-in-chief, told The Post.

Hospitals depended on to help patients.

The investigation will look at data on 12,000 patients treated for COVID-19 in .

Around 2,000 of the patients in the group were placed on ventilators – some for a few days, and others for a longer period.

Over two-thirds of the patients placed on the breathing machines in March and April died at Northwell facilities, The Post reported.

Numbers were similar for other hospitals.

McGinn added that doctors are evaluating if "other non-invasive" measures should have been used first.

U.S. Army Specialist Fredrick Spencer assembles a ventilator machine at the temporary hospital set up at the Javits Center in New York City
6
U.S. Army Specialist Fredrick Spencer assembles a ventilator machine at the temporary hospital set up at the Javits Center in New York CityCredit: Reuters
A nurse operates a ventilator for a patient who was revived after going into cardiac arrest aat St. Joseph's Hospital in Yonkers
6
A nurse operates a ventilator for a patient who was revived after going into cardiac arrest aat St. Joseph's Hospital in YonkersCredit: AP:Associated Press

"A big question is, can you delay putting patients on a ventilator or never put them on?” McGinn asked.

While the probe is evaluating the effects of the ventilators, McGinn emphasized the importance of the machine in saving lives.

“Vents don’t cause deaths. They save lives," he told The Post.

"If we didn’t put them on a vent they would all die."

As the coronavirus pandemic began to spread across the US, governors and hospital workers begged for more ventilators, amid fears that a shortage of the machines would cause avoidable deaths.

At the end of March, invoked the

Both New York Gov and Mayor said they needed more ventilators, as they warned they would run out.

"At the current burn rate, ," Cuomo said on April 1.

"The burn rate is troubling and six days of ventilators is troubling. But we have all these extraordinary measures."

Two nurses evaluate a patient on a ventilator machine at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Brooklyn, New York
6
Two nurses evaluate a patient on a ventilator machine at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Brooklyn, New YorkCredit: Getty Images - Getty
Nic Brown is seen on a ventilator at Cleveland Clinic in Ohio
6
Nic Brown is seen on a ventilator at Cleveland Clinic in OhioCredit: Reuters

Days later, the .

"Am I seizing vents? No, I’m taking excess equipment to save lives," Cuomo said.

"It’s about doing the right thing to save lives."

The state also .

Topics