Jump directly to the content
United in failure

Manchester United vs Liverpool: The worst combined XI as the two giants of Premier League football get set to do battle on Sunday afternoon

Ahead of Sunday's showdown at Old Trafford talkSPORT take a look at the least talented players to ever turn out for the clubs

MANCHESTER UNITED and Liverpool are the two most successful teams in English football history.

Their rivalry is also the most fierce in the Premier League, but now, ahead of Sunday's massive showdown at Old Trafford, we take a look at the slightly less successful side of the two clubs.

Jurgen Klopp is set to go head-to-head with Jose Mourinho this weekend
14
Jurgen Klopp is set to go head-to-head with Jose Mourinho this weekend as Manchester United take on Liverpool at Old Trafford in the Premier LeagueCredit: Getty Images

With a little help from , we pick the WORST ever Manchester United-Liverpool combined XI, with amazing results.


Keep up to date with ALL the Liverpool and Manchester United news, gossip, transfers and goals on our club page plus fixtures, results and live match commentary.


Take a look for yourself, below...

14

GOALKEEPER: Massimo Taibi

Massimo Taibi is easily the worst goalkeeper in Premier League history
14
Massimo Taibi is easily the worst goalkeeper in Premier League historyCredit: PA:Press Association

REPLACING Peter Schmeichel was always going to be a monumental task, but Sir Alex Ferguson got it so, so wrong with Taibi.

The Italian signed in 1999, played just four games making a spate of horrendous errors leading to goals, including letting a tame shot slip between his legs against Southampton in a 3-3 draw.

The 5-0 humiliation at the hands of Chelsea saw the end of him... and those Julian Speroni-style tracksuit bottoms.

RIGHT-BACK: Philipp Degen

Philipp Degen signed for Liverpool alongside fellow sub-par full-back Andrea Dossena
14
Philipp Degen signed for Liverpool alongside fellow sub-par full-back Andrea DossenaCredit: Reuters

SWISS full-back Degen was the last in a string of appalling right-backs at Liverpool in the late-00s, following Josemi and Jan Kromkamp.

Fortunately almost always deputising for Steve Finnan, Degen rarely took to the pitch for Liverpool.

He was so disliked - as a player - at the club, that Kop idol Jamie Carragher once tweeted: "Thought the night couldn't get any worse but it has... Philipp Degen is now warming up in front of me."

CENTRE-BACK: Mauricio Pellegrino

Mauricio Pellegrino was one of the slowest players to grace the Premier League
14
Mauricio Pellegrino was one of the slowest players to grace the Premier LeagueCredit: News Group Newspapers Ltd

ONCE dubbed 'slower than evolution' on a Liverpool fan site, Pellegrino signed back in 2005 from Valencia.

The brutal speed of the Premier League exposed the Argentine's most fatal flaw, as he went on to make just 14 appearances.

In fact, following a shambolic performance in a 2-0 loss to Southampton, former Reds star Alan Hansen described it as 'the worst performance I've seen since I left the club in 1990'.

CENTRE-BACK: William Prunier

William Prunier was one of Sir Alex Fergusons greatest mistakes
14
William Prunier was one of Sir Alex Ferguson's greatest mistakesCredit: PA:Press Association

FAMOUSLY remembered for being Eric Cantona's friend from France, the centre-back was one of the worst players to ever pull on the United shirt.

Prunier played just twice for the club, including a 4-1 drubbing at the hands of Tottenham, where his first touch was a sprayed pass to absolutely no-one - summing up his career rather succinctly.

Even Fergie described him as a 'disaster'. Ouch.

LEFT-BACK: Djimi Traore

Djimi Traore was famously error-prone during his time at Liverpool
14
Djimi Traore was famously error-prone during his time at Liverpool

'DON'T blame it on the Biscan, don’t blame it on the Hamann, don’t blame it on the Finnan, blame it on Traore. He just can’t, he just can’t, he just can’t control his feet...'

That's what Liverpool fans would aptly sing - to the tune of Blame It On The Boogie - to the error-prone defender, who famously scored one of the worst own goals in history against Burnley.

The only slightly redeeming quality was helping Liverpool win the 2005 Champions League final against AC Milan during the Miracle of Istanbul.

CENTRAL MIDFIELD: Eric Djemba-Djemba

Eric Djemba-Djemba spent two difficult years at Manchester United
14
Eric Djemba-Djemba spent two difficult years at Manchester UnitedCredit: EMPICS Sport

AS the old saying goes - 'So bad they named him twice' - Djemba-Djemba has edged out the woeful Kleberson and Liam Miller into this XI.

He even signed at the same time as a young forward called Cristiano Ronaldo, making the deal look all the more spectacularly poor.

Djemba-Djemba was sold to Aston Villa, where he continued to leave fans underwhelmed...

CENTRAL MIDFIELD: Salif Diao

Salif Diao was slated by Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher
14
Salif Diao was slated by Liverpool legend Jamie CarragherCredit: AFP

BROUGHT into Liverpool on the back of Senegal's successful World Cup campaign in 2002 - along with the controversial El-Hadji Diouf - Diao was an instant Reds flop.

In fact, club legend Carragher even said of the midfielder: "He couldn't pass, was a liability when he tackled and never looked capable of scoring a goal. And they were his good qualities."

Never one to mince his words, Carra...

CENTRAL MIDFIELD: Christian Poulsen

Christian Poulsen joined Liverpool with a wealth of European pedigree
14
Christian Poulsen joined Liverpool with a wealth of European pedigreeCredit: EMPICS Sport

ARGUABLY the worst of Roy Hodgson's dreadful Liverpool signings - which included Paul Konchesky and a well past-it Joe Cole.

The Danish midfielder came in with a superb reputation, so Roy can be forgiven.

But when Jay Spearing is keeping you out of the first XI, you know your days are numbered.

RIGHT WING: Antonio Nunez

Antonio Nunez was part of the Michael Owen to Real Madrid transfer
14
Antonio Nunez was part of the Michael Owen to Real Madrid transferCredit: PA:Press Association

PART of the incredible deal which saw star forward Michael Owen join Real Madrid, Nunez will never be forgotten at Anfield.

The  winger was so out of place at Liverpool that many assumed he was a Bernabeu steward who 'pulled an Ali Dia'.

Quite how Nunez managed to have Real and the Reds on his CV is a simply staggering feat...

RIGHT WING: Milan Jovanovic

Milan Jovanovic only earned a handful of appearances at Liverpool
14
Milan Jovanovic only earned a handful of appearances at LiverpoolCredit: EMPICS Sport

ANOTHER Roy-era player, the speedy winger somehow racked up 18 appearances for Liverpool.

Famously part of the team who lost to lowly Northampton in the League Cup, that was as good as it got for Jovanovic.

Even on a free, the Reds overspent on the Serbian.

STRIKER: Bebe

Bebe moved from Vitoria Guimaraes to United in 2010 for £7million
14
Bebe moved from Vitoria Guimaraes to United in 2010 for £7millionCredit: Action Images

THE forward famed for being the man 'Fergie watched on YouTube' Bebe was a Premier League flop of the highest order.

United splashed £7m on the Portuguese ace when Dutch side PSV Eindhoven declined him for nothing.

On Bebe, Ferguson could only exclaim: "Football, bloody hell."

MANAGER: Roy Hodgson

Roy Hodgson endured a miserable spell at Liverpool, lasting just four months
14
Roy Hodgson endured a miserable spell at Liverpool, lasting just four months

DAVID MOYES, Louis van Gaal and Kenny Dalglish's most recent stint don't even come close to Hodgson's ill-fated stint at Liverpool.

The former Fulham boss made a series of atrocious signings - many of which made this XI - and was even the man in charge for that Cobblers cup car crash.

Hodgson lasted just four months at Anfield.

Topics